Password Generator vs doing it by hand — which is faster?
Picking a password by hand feels quick: you think of a word, add a number and a symbol, and you are done in half a minute. The Password Generator is quicker still — one click, under a second — and the password it makes is far stronger. The honest comparison is not really about speed, though. It is about randomness, because a password picked by a person is never as random as it looks.
At a glance
By hand: about 30 seconds, and biased
Try making a 16-character password by hand. You have to pick 16 characters one by one, check you have mixed cases, digits and symbols, and count to 16 as you go, which takes about 30 seconds for most people. Worse, the result is biased: people favour letters they like, put digits at the end, use symbols like ! in familiar spots, and quietly reuse patterns from old passwords. A hand-picked password often contains a word or a date, and attackers try words and dates first. The time is not the problem; the predictability is.
With the tool: under a second, and truly random
With the defaults — length 16, all four sets ticked — the tool picks 16 characters from the 89-character pool using your browser’s cryptographic random source, and shows the password and its entropy, about 104 bits, at once. There are 89 to the power of 16 possible results, about 1.5 followed by 31 zeroes, and every one of them is equally likely. No character is favoured, no pattern repeats, and the password has no word in it for a dictionary attack to find. An illustrative result of that shape is “Tq4!wZ8#eR1@pL6s”: 16 characters, mixed case, digits and symbols, with nothing memorable about it. That string is only an illustration, so generate your own.
A second comparison: changing the length
Suppose you want a 20-character password for a Wi-Fi router. By hand that is another slow round of picking and counting, and most people give up and reuse the old one. With the tool you drag the slider from 16 to 20 and press Generate, which takes about two seconds, and the entropy rises from about 104 bits to about 130 bits. The cost of a longer password with the tool is nothing; by hand it is more time and more chance of a mistake.
When doing it by hand still makes sense
There is one case where hand-picking wins: a short code you must type often and cannot store anywhere, such as a phone PIN. For anything stored in a password manager, which is every website password, the tool wins outright. The manager remembers the password, so its randomness costs you nothing and its length costs you nothing either.
The common mistake
People split the difference: they generate a password with the tool, then edit a few characters to make it “easier”. That reintroduces exactly the bias the tool removed, and a password with a word swapped in can fall to a dictionary attack even at 16 characters. Use the tool’s password exactly as it comes out, and let the password manager remember it.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Password Generator faster than picking a password by hand?
Yes. The tool makes a 16-character password in under a second, while picking 16 characters by hand takes about 30 seconds, and the tool’s result is far more random.
Why is a hand-picked password weaker?
Because people favour familiar letters, put digits at the end, use symbols in familiar spots, and reuse words and dates, all of which attackers try first.
How strong is the tool’s default password?
About 104 bits. It is 16 characters from an 89-character pool, giving 89 to the power of 16 possible passwords, about 1.5 followed by 31 zeroes.
When is picking a password by hand fine?
For a short code you must type often and cannot store anywhere, such as a phone PIN. For website passwords, use the tool and a password manager.
More guides on the Password Generator
- How to use the Password Generator — step by step
- Password Generator explained with worked examples
- Password Generator formula — how it actually works
- Password Generator for beginners — start here
- Common mistakes people make with the Password Generator
- Password Generator — the complete guide
- How to get an accurate result from the Password Generator
- Password Generator for students — with examples
- Password Generator for homeowners and DIYers
Try the Password Generator — free, in your browser.