← All blog posts

Common mistakes people make with the Ideal Weight Calculator

WhiteUI · A plain-English guide to the Ideal Weight Calculator

Most wrong ideal-weight answers come from the numbers typed in, not the formula. These are the five slips that show up most often, each with the numbers that catch it — so you can spot them in your own calculation before you trust the answer. The example all through this page is a 175 cm man: the correct answer is 70.5 kg, with a healthy range of 56.7 kg to 76.3 kg.

The five mistakes

  1. Typing inches as centimetres. A 5-foot-9 person is 69 inches tall. Type 69 into the centimetre box and the calculator works out 50 + 2.3 × (27.17 − 60) = −25.5 kg. A negative weight is impossible — the height went in wrong.
  2. Typing metres as centimetres. Type 1.75 instead of 175 and the answer is 50 + 2.3 × (0.69 − 60) = −86.4 kg. Again impossible, same cause: the box expects centimetres.
  3. Picking the wrong sex. The two formulas differ by exactly 4.5 kg at any height. Pick female by mistake at 175 cm and you get 66.0 kg instead of 70.5 kg.
  4. Treating the single number as a target. The Devine ideal is one old formula’s midpoint, not a goal. At 175 cm the healthy range is 56.7 kg to 76.3 kg — 19.6 kg wide — and any weight inside it is inside the healthy BMI band.
  5. Forgetting the range is the answer. Some people read only the big number and miss the range underneath it. The range carries the useful information; the single figure is just one point inside it.

Worked example — mistake 1 in numbers

Correct: 175 cm is 68.90 inches, 8.90 over 5 feet, so 50 + 2.3 × 8.90 = 70.5 kg. Wrong: 69 typed as centimetres is 27.17 inches, which is 32.83 inches under 5 feet, so 50 + 2.3 × (−32.83) = −25.5 kg. The wrong answer is off by 96 kg — and the minus sign is the giveaway.

Correct: 175 cm → 68.90 in → 50 + 2.3 × 8.90 = 70.5 kg
Wrong:   69 typed as cm → 27.17 in → 50 + 2.3 × (−32.83) = −25.5 kg

At a glance

At 175 cm, three points on the rangeBottom of healthy range — 56.7 kgDevine ideal — 70.5 kgTop of healthy range — 76.3 kgThe range is 19.6 kg wide. The single ideal figure is just one point inside it — not a pass mark.

The range is 19.6 kg wide. The single ideal figure is just one point inside it — not a pass mark.

How to check your own answer

Three quick checks catch most slips. First, the answer must be positive and roughly between 40 kg and 90 kg for an adult — a negative number means the height went in wrong. Second, the woman’s figure at your height is exactly 4.5 kg below the man’s, so flip the sex and check the gap. Third, try the calculator’s own example: 175 cm as a man should give 70.5 kg and a range of 56.7 kg to 76.3 kg.

Informational only, not medical advice. This is an estimate, not a diagnosis. For personal advice, talk to a clinician.

Devine vs BMI: why the two answers are different numbers

The calculator gives two answers, and they look like they disagree. For the 175 cm man from the example above, the Devine ideal is 70.5 kg, while the healthy range is 56.7 kg to 76.3 kg. They are not two guesses at the same thing: Devine is one point — the weight the 1974 formula assigns to that height — and the range is the span of weights that puts the BMI between 18.5 and 24.9.

The point sits inside the range, 13.8 kg above the bottom and 5.8 kg below the top. That is the useful way to read them: the range is the answer to “am I roughly fine?”, and the single number is a landmark inside it. A man at 70 kg is near the Devine figure and inside the range; a man at 80 kg is only about 10 kg above the Devine figure, but he is above the range — and it is the range that matters for the decision.

What to check before you trust the number

Three checks, in the order that catches the most errors. First, the height unit: the box takes centimetres, and a height typed in inches or feet gives a nonsense answer — the worked example on this page shows what happens. Second, the sex: at any height the men’s and women’s answers differ by 4.5 kg, so at 175 cm a man’s ideal is 70.5 kg and a woman’s is 66.0 kg. Picking the wrong one shifts the answer by that full 4.5 kg.

Third, the height itself: measure barefoot, in the morning, back against a wall. Then check the answer against the range — at 168 cm, for example, a man’s ideal is 64.1 kg and a woman’s is 59.6 kg, and both sit inside the healthy range of 52.2 kg to 70.3 kg. If the single number falls outside its own range, the height or the sex was typed wrong.

Frequently asked questions

Why did I get a negative ideal weight?

Your height went in in the wrong unit. The box expects centimetres — 175, not 69 inches and not 1.75 metres. Anything under about 100 cm pushes the formula below zero.

I typed 5.9 for 5 feet 9 inches — why is the answer wrong?

The calculator takes one number in centimetres. 5 feet 9 inches is 69 inches, and 69 × 2.54 = 175.26 cm. Type 175, not 5.9.

Does picking the wrong sex matter much?

It shifts the answer by exactly 4.5 kg — the gap between the 50 kg and 45.5 kg starting weights. At 175 cm, a man gets 70.5 kg and a woman 66.0 kg.

My weight is inside the range but not at the ideal — is that fine?

Yes. The range is the healthy BMI band, 18.5 to 24.9. Any weight inside it is inside the band, and the single ideal figure is just one point within it.

More guides on the Ideal Weight Calculator

Try it yourself

A free calculator that shows a healthy weight range and the Devine ideal weight for your height, for men and women.

Open the Ideal Weight Calculator